Utilising the IRAC structure (issues: rules: application: conclusion). The task is a common law assignment, so you are not required to discuss any legislation at all. It is essential that you cite relevant authorities (cases) wherever possible to support your reasoning in each answer.

Scenairo 3: Monalisa cleans out her parents' household fridge and cupboard to make the sandwiches and cakes. Monalisa's mum Ann asks Monalisa to pay her back for the ingredients but Monalisa refuses. Ann contacts Nal directly and says, 'Monalisa has used all my ingredients - you need to give me $1000 out of the $4000 they are to be paid to reimburse me'.

Question 3. Does Nal need to pay $1000 to Monalisa's mother Ann?