When companies engage in comparative advertising, making explicit comparisons between their products and those of com-...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
![When companies engage in comparative advertising, making explicit comparisons between their products and](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/si.experts.images/questions/2023/09/6512b0a3eb65a_1695723681406.jpg)
Transcribed Image Text:
When companies engage in comparative advertising, making explicit comparisons between their products and those of com- petitors, complaints of false statements and defamation are fairly common. In that sense, a lawsuit that Subway recently filed against Quiznos is not in itself unusual. Subway claimed that Quiznos made unfair and untrue comparisons about the size and meat content of one of its sandwiches and failed to disclose the fact that the larger Quiznos sandwich cost nearly twice as much as the Subway sandwich. What made this case unusual and gave it potentially far- reaching impact for business communication is the Web 2.0 angle of user-generated content (UGC). As part of its efforts to promote this particular sandwich, Quiznos sponsored a contest in which members of the public were invited to create their own commercials. The contest encouraged people to highlight the "meat, no meat" theme, suggesting that the Quiznos sandwich had copious amounts of beef, while the Subway sandwich had far less. More than 100 people submitted videos, which were posted to a Quiznos website and to iFilm, a now-defunct video clip website owned by the media giant Viacom. Subway's lawsuit claimed that some of the videos contained false and disparaging content for which Quiznos and iFilm should be held liable. Subway asserted that Quiznos specifically encouraged contestants to promote one product at the expense of the other, so it should not be immune from responsibility. Quiznos's lawyers responded by pointing out that the company did not create these videos and was therefore not liable. "We're just facilitating consumers who go out and create their own expression in the form of a commercial." Quiznos first tried to have the UGC part of the lawsuit dismissed by claiming the same immunity that YouTube and similar services have regarding the content that members of the public post on their websites. However, a judge refused, saying the law protecting YouTube (the Communications Decency Act, or CDA) didn't necessarily protect Quiznos in this case. Quinzos subsequently asked for a summary judgment to avoid going to trial. When that request was also denied, the two companies settled out of court. That private settlement closed the dispute between the two sandwich chains, but it left the matter of legal responsibility for UGC campaigns wide open. The central question is how much involvement a company sponsoring a UGC contest has in the content of the submissions. The court indicated that by spon- soring the contest and presenting the contest guidelines in a particular way, Quiznos played some role in the creation of the videos. However, because the case didn't go to trial, the ques- tion of whether that role was significant enough to strip the company of legal immunity under the CDA is still unresolved. Until clear legal guidelines are established, companies running UGC programs, such as Toyota's Auto-Biography campaign, will need to tread carefully to avoid legal problems. CAREER APPLICATIONS 1. Legal issues aside, in your opinion, is Quiznos ethically re- sponsible for any false or misleading information that may be found in the user-generated videos? Why or why not? 2. Most consumers lack the skills and equipment needed to produce professional-quality video commercials. Why would companies such as Quiznos invite them to create commercials? When companies engage in comparative advertising, making explicit comparisons between their products and those of com- petitors, complaints of false statements and defamation are fairly common. In that sense, a lawsuit that Subway recently filed against Quiznos is not in itself unusual. Subway claimed that Quiznos made unfair and untrue comparisons about the size and meat content of one of its sandwiches and failed to disclose the fact that the larger Quiznos sandwich cost nearly twice as much as the Subway sandwich. What made this case unusual and gave it potentially far- reaching impact for business communication is the Web 2.0 angle of user-generated content (UGC). As part of its efforts to promote this particular sandwich, Quiznos sponsored a contest in which members of the public were invited to create their own commercials. The contest encouraged people to highlight the "meat, no meat" theme, suggesting that the Quiznos sandwich had copious amounts of beef, while the Subway sandwich had far less. More than 100 people submitted videos, which were posted to a Quiznos website and to iFilm, a now-defunct video clip website owned by the media giant Viacom. Subway's lawsuit claimed that some of the videos contained false and disparaging content for which Quiznos and iFilm should be held liable. Subway asserted that Quiznos specifically encouraged contestants to promote one product at the expense of the other, so it should not be immune from responsibility. Quiznos's lawyers responded by pointing out that the company did not create these videos and was therefore not liable. "We're just facilitating consumers who go out and create their own expression in the form of a commercial." Quiznos first tried to have the UGC part of the lawsuit dismissed by claiming the same immunity that YouTube and similar services have regarding the content that members of the public post on their websites. However, a judge refused, saying the law protecting YouTube (the Communications Decency Act, or CDA) didn't necessarily protect Quiznos in this case. Quinzos subsequently asked for a summary judgment to avoid going to trial. When that request was also denied, the two companies settled out of court. That private settlement closed the dispute between the two sandwich chains, but it left the matter of legal responsibility for UGC campaigns wide open. The central question is how much involvement a company sponsoring a UGC contest has in the content of the submissions. The court indicated that by spon- soring the contest and presenting the contest guidelines in a particular way, Quiznos played some role in the creation of the videos. However, because the case didn't go to trial, the ques- tion of whether that role was significant enough to strip the company of legal immunity under the CDA is still unresolved. Until clear legal guidelines are established, companies running UGC programs, such as Toyota's Auto-Biography campaign, will need to tread carefully to avoid legal problems. CAREER APPLICATIONS 1. Legal issues aside, in your opinion, is Quiznos ethically re- sponsible for any false or misleading information that may be found in the user-generated videos? Why or why not? 2. Most consumers lack the skills and equipment needed to produce professional-quality video commercials. Why would companies such as Quiznos invite them to create commercials?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Analyzing the situation involving Quiznos and Subway we can discuss the ethical and strategic aspects of their actions 1 Ethical Responsibility of Qui... View the full answer
Related Book For
Financial Reporting Financial Statement Analysis and Valuation a strategic perspective
ISBN: 978-1337614689
9th edition
Authors: James M. Wahlen, Stephen P. Baginski, Mark Bradshaw
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these business communication questions
-
Calculate the indicated ratios for Barry. Do not round intermediate calculations. Round your answers to two decimal places. Ratio Barry Industry Average Current 1.69 1.65 Quick 0.97 0.92 Days sales...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Googles ease of use and superior search results have propelled the search engine to its num- ber one status, ousting the early dominance of competitors such as WebCrawler and Infos- eek. Even later...
-
The Commerce Department reported that in December 2015, retail sales rose by 0.2, net exports decreased, inventories held by businesses rose by 0.1 percent, and total sales by businesses fell by 0.6...
-
List all employees.
-
A process to produce Product "A" has four sequential steps. Step one takes 12 minutes, step two takes 8 minutes, step three takes 6 minutes and step four takes 10 minutes. The business operates 8...
-
Why is knowledge of incoterms important to importers and exporters? LO.1
-
How important is it that the warehouse bins and invoices are coded inconsistently? Respond in a paragraph. What are some of the problems created when a code appears to be mnemonic but employees are...
-
10. Refer to the following financial statements for Crosby Corporation: CROSBY CORPORATION Income Statement For the Year Ended December 31, 20X2 Sales $4,110,000 Cost of goods sold 2,680,000 Gross...
-
On June 1, Year 1, Tsanumis Corporation (a U.S.-based manufacturing firm) received an order to sell goods to a foreign customer at a price of 1 million euros. The goods will be shipped and payment...
-
multiple choice Critical literacy can be judged to be effective to the extent that it equips people to effectively question unequal power relations. contributes to social stability. overthrows the...
-
Critical Values. In Exercises 41-44, find the indicated critical value. Round results to two decimal places. 41. Z0.25 42. Z090 43. Z0.02 44. Z0.05
-
Case Study X Ltd. has 10 lakhs equity shares outstanding at the beginning of the accounting year 2016. The appropriate P/E ratio for the industry in which D Ltd. is 8.35. The earnings per share is...
-
Notation of 0 + Using the same survey described in Exercise 1, the probability of randomly selecting 50 speaking characters from movies and getting 40 females is expressed as 0+. Does 0+ indicate...
-
A simple random sample of 10 pages from a dictionary is obtained. The numbers of words defined on those pages are found, with the results n = 10, x = 66.4 words, s = 16.6 words. Given that this...
-
Question 3 58.5 Average global temperature 1880-2013 58.0 $ 57.5 57.0 56.5 1880 1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 2020 Year The graph above indicates that global temperatures have Ovaried randomly over...
-
Debit Credit Cash 6,200 Accounts receivable 86,300 Inventory 16,400 Prepaid insurance 3,500 Land 40,000 Equipment 812,000 Buildings 1,200,000 Accumulated depreciation 560,000 Patent 12,000 Copyright...
-
Select the correct answer for each of the following questions. 1. On December 31, 20X3, Saxe Corporation was merged into Poe Corporation. In the business combination, Poe issued 200,000 shares of its...
-
Prepaid Legal Services (PPD) is a company that sells insurance for legal expenses. Customers pay premiums in advance for coverage over some specified period. Thus, PPD obtains cash but has unearned...
-
Explain required income. What does required income represent? How is required income conceptually analogous to interest expense?
-
When a firm incurs costs on an item to be used in operations, management must decide whether to treat the cost as an asset or an expense. Assume that a company used cash to acquire machinery expected...
-
Purchased debt instrument with impairment LO9, 11, 13, 14 On 1 January 2019, Biko Banking Ltd purchases a debt instrument with a 5-year term for its fair value of $1000 million (including...
-
Applying accounting theory LO6, 8, 13, 14 Tropical Tours Ltd needs to raise $500 000 to finance the acquisition of a new tour bus. It approached an investment bank that proposed the following...
-
Various financial assets and financial liabilities LO12, 13 Great Adventure Ltd has entered into a number of contracts that are financial instruments as follows. (a) On 1 July 2018, the company...
![Mobile App Logo](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/includes/images/mobile/finalLogo.png)
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App