. X brings a preliminary Charter motion at the beginning of his Ontario Review Board hearing, alleging that the process infringes his rights. As an applicant, he wants to know what the government is required to demonstrate and what the possible outcomes are.

Y is a RCIC who is arguing her first hearing at an administrative tribunal. In her research, Mary has found a Supreme Court of Canada decision that is directly on point. What value does the Supreme Court of Canada decision hold at the administrative tribunal hearing?