Answer questions with explanations.

swer. 3. What 4. What would you do if you were Ms. Case StudyThe Clean Linens de su returned to college in the fall. good job. I'm counting on you," he warned. was a lovely family resort and she felt lucky to have the summer job before she Patty was a housekeeper at the Sommerset Hotel and Lodge on Lake Superior On this particular day, Patty was in a hurry to finish her work. Both her mom Penelope from ballet class. She had explained the situation to Mr. Gibson, her boss, and dad were out of town on business and she had to pick up her younger sister who told her she could leave as soon as her work was done. "But do your usual Patty was getting nervous because time was of the essence. She didn't want her six-year-old sister to have to wait. She entered her last room, room number 12, and found it in good order. She was relieved to think she could be in and out in just a few minutes. The room had two double beds and one had obviously not been slept in. She changed the linens only on the one that had been slept in, even though she knew she should change both. She gave the bathroom a good scrubbing, changed the towels, vacuumed the floors, dusted accordingly, and was done. She was on her way five minutes after she finished cleaning room number 12 She arrived at Penelope's ballet class just as it was finishing. Penelope chatted all the way home and Patty was relieved to see this day come to an end. When her parents came home later that evening, she told them what a close call she had had. Everyone was relieved that the day had ended well. The next day when Patty arrived at work, she was called to Mr. Gibson's office. Within two minutes of entering, she was fired. A couple had checked into room number 12. When they went to sleep that night, they were horrified by the dirty stained sheets they found. Mr. Gibson did not care how or why it happened . happened and it was her room, so she was fired. Case Questions 1. What are the justice issues in this case? Is the retribution appropriate? Explain your answer. 2. From a utilitarian viewpoint, is Mr. Gibson's decision justified? Why or wh not? 3. How would Kant view this situation? What are Patty's duties? 4. How would Aristotle view the situation? What would he say about Patt- What would he say about Mr. Gibson