Question: check answer against other AI answer; correct as needed: To determine the best choice for improving the process capacity within the budget constraints, we need

check answer against other AI answer; correct as needed:
To determine the best choice for improving the process capacity within the budget constraints, we need to consider both the time taken for each step and the cost of the machines. The goal is to reduce the bottleneck in the process while staying within the $1,000 budget.
First, let's identify the bottleneck. The bottleneck is the step in the process that takes the longest time per unit, as this step limits the overall throughput. In this case:
Step 1 takes 30 seconds per unit.
Step 2 takes 20 seconds per unit.
Step 3 takes 15 seconds per unit.
Step 4 takes 10 seconds per unit.
The bottleneck is Step 1, which takes 30 seconds per unit.
Next, let's evaluate the cost of each machine and how many of each can be purchased within the $1,000 budget:
Machine 1 cost: $800
Machine 2 cost: $400
Machine 3 cost: $200
Machine 4 cost: $500
Based on the budget:
One Machine 1 can be purchased for $800.
Two Machine 2s can be purchased for $800.
Five Machine 3s can be purchased for $1,000.
Two Machine 4s can be purchased for $1,000.
Two Machine 2s and one Machine 3 can be purchased for $1,000.
Since the bottleneck is at Step 1, we should prioritize purchasing Machine 1 to address this bottleneck. Therefore, the best choice within the budget to improve process capacity would be:
a. One Machine 1
This choice focuses on reducing the time of the slowest step, thereby increasing overall process efficiency.
ChatGPT
The analysis provided by the other AI correctly identifies the bottleneck and considers the budget constraints. It is important to note that while addressing the bottleneck is crucial, it's also essential to consider the total time reduction per unit that can be achieved within the budget.
Let's reassess with this in mind:
Bottleneck: Step 1 is indeed the bottleneck at 30 seconds per unit.
Machine Costs and Time Reductions:
Machine 1: $800, reduces the bottleneck by 30 seconds.
Machine 2: $400, reduces time by 20 seconds per unit.
Machine 3: $200, reduces time by 15 seconds per unit.
Machine 4: $500, reduces time by 10 seconds per unit.
Budget Options:
One Machine 1: Addresses the bottleneck directly but leaves a remaining $200 in the budget unused.
Two Machine 2s: Costs $800, reduces time by 40 seconds per unit in total.
Five Machine 3s: Fully utilizes the budget and provides a total time reduction of 75 seconds per unit.
Two Machine 4s: Fully utilizes the budget but offers the least total time reduction (20 seconds per unit).
Two Machine 2s and one Machine 3: Utilizes the full budget, with a total time reduction of 55 seconds per unit.
Given that addressing the bottleneck is crucial, and the budget allows for more flexibility, the best choice might indeed be:
a. One Machine 1
This option directly addresses the bottleneck. Although it does not use the full budget, it targets the most time-consuming step, which is a critical factor in process improvement. The remaining budget might not be enough to purchase another machine that would significantly contribute to further reducing the overall process time.

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related General Management Questions!