Compose a concise document using the IRAC method and limit your answer to the following guidelines for the scenario below

(1) An Issue Statement (one sentence);

(2) A Statement of the General Rule (one sentence);

(3) An Analysis of the rules to the facts of the case (two paragraphs); and

(4) A Conclusion (one paragraph).

Notice and Access to Evidence Problem Every morning, Smith picks up his colleagues Jones and Grey and they all carpool to work. Smith drives an old car with lots of miles on it. One morning, on the way to the office, Smith was in a car accident with Barnett. Everyone suffered personal injuries in the accident, including the two passengers in Smith's car, and both cars were wrecked. Barnett sued Smith for negligence in federal district court. (Assume that subject matter jurisdiction is proper in federal district court). Barnett served on Smith the following request for documents: Produce for inspection, or copying any and all documents related to Smith's driving record, Smith's medical records, including psychiatric care, and Smith's alcohol and drug use. In addition, produce for inspection or copying any and all documents related to automobile repair and maintenance for Smith's car. Must Smith comply with the document request described? What is Smith's best argument against compliance?