Question: i) Outline the central constitutional issues raised in the Reference re Firearms Act (Can.), [2000] 1 S.C.R. 783 case. ii) Briefly outline the reasons for

i) Outline the central constitutional issues raised in the Reference re Firearms Act (Can.), [2000] 1 S.C.R. 783 case.

ii) Briefly outline the reasons for the final decision.

iii) What was at stake (politically and/or legally speaking) in this case? Do you agree with the decision rendered by the court? Provide persuasive reasons for your position.

Possible issues to explore: effect on the character of Canadian Federalism, judicial activism versus deference, common law and case law coherence/consistency, practical decision-making versus principled/abstract adjudication, and the issue of efficacy versus legality. This list is not exhaustive. These are merely suggestions.

Step by Step Solution

★★★★★

3.46 Rating (146 Votes )

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer

Step: 1 Unlock

i The Reference re Firearms Act Can 2000 1 SCR 783 also known as the Firearms Reference is a leading Supreme Court of Canada decision on the division of powers between the federal and provincial gover... View full answer

Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock

Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Law Questions!

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the lower court ruling in the case Public Employees Retirement Association of Colorado; Generic Trading of Philadelphia, LLC v. Deloitte...

The purpose of this case is to provide you with an example of a decision setting in which we will explore the ethical issues involved in conducting audit procedures. This case is based on an actual...

The human-caused disruption of our global climate poses a graver threat to the human family and its environment unlike any prior problem. As an environmental issue, global climate disruption is...

what is ratio Ratio Decendi and Obiter dicta in canada v EF case? case; [1] It is a criminal offence in Canada to provide assistance to someone who wishes to end their own life. The Criminal Code...

Please brief United States v. Windsor on pages 319-323 in the textbook. I type the text below. Justice Kennedydelivered the opinion of the Court. Two women then resident in New York were marriedin a...

COURT OF APPEAL FOR BRITISH COLUMBIA Citation: Equustek Solutions Inc. v. Google Inc., 2015 BCCA 265 Date: 20150611 Docket: CA41923 Between: Equustek Solutions Inc., Robert Angus and Clarma...

Briefly discuss the three leading approaches to determining the disposition of a pre-embryo upon divorce, as discussed by the Connecticut Supreme Court in Bilbao v. Goodwin : (1) the contractual...

Prof. Patterson Law, Business & Society, Spring 2017 Writing Assignment No. 1 - Hobby Lobby Due Date: Monday, Feb. 13 by 11:55 pm, via Turnitin on NYU Classes You are a young lawyer working for a...

Walter Construction Group Lid v CPL (Surry Hills) Ply Lid [2003] Adj-L.R. 04/09 JUDGMENT : Nicholas J : Supreme Court of New South Wales : 9" April 2003. 1 By Its Notice of Motion the Plaintiff seeks...

RFID (Radio Frequency Identification) Technology in Retailing Information Security Systems You need to make a presentation, including the following things Description Definition Main idea more focus...

A homeowner is granted a mortgage at a rate of 11,4% p.a. compounded monthly. The loan is to be amortised by means of 240 regular equal monthly payments of R5297,74 starting one month after the loan...

Find a formula a n for the n - th term of the following sequence. Assume the series begins at n = 1 . 1 1 , - 1 4 , 1 9 , dots ( Use symbolic notation and fractions where needed. ) Find a formula b n...

Bobe Air uses two measures of activity, flights and passengers, in the cost formulas in its budgets and performance reports. The cost formula for plane operating costs is $44,580 per month plus...

Many children who live in the Slums of Tondo, Manila are developing asthma. In a descriptive study investigating this problem, parents whose children have asthma are asked about whether they smoke...

The solid disc of mass m = 6 kg shown is spinning freely on a shaft of length L = 0.15 m at the rate of 1000 rpm. If the assembly is released from rest in the vertical position at = 0, determine the...

Which of the following items are sold by firms in monopolistic competition? Explain your selections. Orange juice Canned soup Chewing gum Breakfast cereals Corn

Consider the following scenario: a company search engine is employed to allow people to search a large repository. All queries submitted to the system are recorded. A record that contains the id of...

What strengths does this family have? How can you conceptualize their problems in a way that will enable them to use their strengths?

Charles and Jack orally agreed to become partners in a tool and die business. Charles, who had experience in tool and die work, was to operate the business. Jack was to take no active part but was to...

Robert McCart owned and operated an H&R Block tax preparation franchise. When Robert became a district manager for H&R Block, he was not allowed to continue operating a franchise. So, in accordance...

(a) On April 1, Mary Rich, at the solicitation of Super Fur Company, delivered a $3,000 mink coat to the company at its place of business for storage in its vaults until November 1. On the same day,...

Webby Inc. is a web development company. Webbys monthly production function for developing websites is given in Table 12P-2. a. Fill in the marginal product column. b. After which programmer does...

Books for Kids is a not-for-profit organization that runs after-school reading programs in four school districts. Books for Kids is planning a fundraiser to buy new books. Last time it held a...

Suppose that a pharmaceutical company wants to grow in size, but is constrained in the short run by its production capacity. Describe some steps that it can take in the long run to overcome these...