BACKGROUND Wellington Trailers Ltd. (WT) manufactures and sells quality car trailers and is organised in a...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
BACKGROUND Wellington Trailers Ltd. (WT) manufactures and sells quality car trailers and is organised in a divisional structure with three divisions named Chassis , Bodies and Assembly . Each division currently operates as a profit centre, with managers receiving a bonus relating to improvements in divisional profits. The managing director (MD), Geoff Lynne, has called you in as a consultant because he is concerned that the issue of transfer prices between divisions has not been adequately considered. One of WT s core products is the popular, Titan trailer and Geoff has suggested that you concentrate on this product to investigate the transfer pricing issue. DETAIL All three divisions contribute to the Titan trailer and each have the practical capacity to produce 600 units. Chassis makes the chassis and delivers them directly to Assembly. Similarly Bodies makes the bodies and delivers them directly to Assembly. This leaves Assembly to bolt the body onto the chassis and attach all fittings (purchased from outside WT Ltd) to produce a finished trailer ready for sale. The manager of the Assembly division, Roy Orbison, has commissioned a marketing consultant to establish the potential demand for the Titan trailer. Expected sales volumes will depend on the sales price chosen and the relationship is predicted as follows: Sales price Unit sales $3,000 550 $3,500 $4,000 $4,500 $5,000 420 325 250 190 Assembly absorbs fixed overheads on the basis of a practical capacity and the full cost per trailer is shown below: Assembly division costing: Direct labour Direct materials: Chassis Body Fittings Variable overheads Fixed overheads Total cost (10 hours at $40) Direct labour Direct materials Variable overheads Fixed overheads Full cost Mark up Transfer price $ 400 You establish that the two supplying divisions also absorb their fixed overheads on the basis of a practical capacity and transfers between divisions have always been at full cost plus a mark-up of 40%. Details for the Titan trailer, from the Chassis and Bodies Divisions, are as follows: Chassis $ 200 330 50 220 800 320 1,120 1,120 490 390 200 200 2,800 Bodies $ 100 130 20 100 350 140 490 You talk next to the manager of the Cassis division, Bob Dylan, and establish that Chassis would normally sell an equivalent chassis in the competitive external market at $1,000 but has recently made only a few external sales and thus has plenty of spare capacity at present. Roy wants to maximise the profits of his Assembly division. Therefore, using a marginal costing approach, based on the marketing consultant s demand estimates and Assembly s costings based on the present transfer prices (above), Roy has calculated the price-volume combination that maximises Assembly division profits: Price Variable cost/unit Contribution/unit Unit sales Total contribution $ 3,000 2,600 400 550 220,000 $ $ 3,500 4,000 2,600 2,600 900 1,400 420 325 378,000 455,000 $ 4,500 2,600 1,900 250 475,000 $ 5,000 2,600 2,400 190 456,000 Tom Petty, manager of the Bodies division, tells you that Bodies could sell equivalent bodies for $530 in the external market and in fact has had to turn away external business in order to supply Assembly with the bodies they require. REQUIRED Prepare a consultant s report to the MD of Wellington Trailers Ltd, Jeff Lynne. Your report should cover the following: (a) Explain how a firm should arrive at the theoretically optimum transfer price (for maximisation of group profits) and apply this theory to the situation described at WT to calculate revised transfer prices for chassis and bodies supplied to Assembly. Give full reasons for your choice of transfer price. (b) Using the transfer prices determined in (a) above, produce a revised Assembly division costing for the Titan trailer, a revised marginal costing operating statement and state the price-volume combination that now maximises profits for Assembly division. Compare this price-volume combination to the one based on the old transfer prices. (c) Explain the key characteristics of a good transfer pricing system and use these to outline the advantages and disadvantages of the theoretically optimum transfer prices suggested in (a). (d) State and briefly explain the range of possible transfer prices within which Bob Dylan (Chassis) and Roy Orbison (Assembly) might seek agreement, if they were free to negotiate a transfer price for chassis. Establish whether they would be likely to reach agreement, and if so at about what price? BACKGROUND Wellington Trailers Ltd. (WT) manufactures and sells quality car trailers and is organised in a divisional structure with three divisions named Chassis , Bodies and Assembly . Each division currently operates as a profit centre, with managers receiving a bonus relating to improvements in divisional profits. The managing director (MD), Geoff Lynne, has called you in as a consultant because he is concerned that the issue of transfer prices between divisions has not been adequately considered. One of WT s core products is the popular, Titan trailer and Geoff has suggested that you concentrate on this product to investigate the transfer pricing issue. DETAIL All three divisions contribute to the Titan trailer and each have the practical capacity to produce 600 units. Chassis makes the chassis and delivers them directly to Assembly. Similarly Bodies makes the bodies and delivers them directly to Assembly. This leaves Assembly to bolt the body onto the chassis and attach all fittings (purchased from outside WT Ltd) to produce a finished trailer ready for sale. The manager of the Assembly division, Roy Orbison, has commissioned a marketing consultant to establish the potential demand for the Titan trailer. Expected sales volumes will depend on the sales price chosen and the relationship is predicted as follows: Sales price Unit sales $3,000 550 $3,500 $4,000 $4,500 $5,000 420 325 250 190 Assembly absorbs fixed overheads on the basis of a practical capacity and the full cost per trailer is shown below: Assembly division costing: Direct labour Direct materials: Chassis Body Fittings Variable overheads Fixed overheads Total cost (10 hours at $40) Direct labour Direct materials Variable overheads Fixed overheads Full cost Mark up Transfer price $ 400 You establish that the two supplying divisions also absorb their fixed overheads on the basis of a practical capacity and transfers between divisions have always been at full cost plus a mark-up of 40%. Details for the Titan trailer, from the Chassis and Bodies Divisions, are as follows: Chassis $ 200 330 50 220 800 320 1,120 1,120 490 390 200 200 2,800 Bodies $ 100 130 20 100 350 140 490 You talk next to the manager of the Cassis division, Bob Dylan, and establish that Chassis would normally sell an equivalent chassis in the competitive external market at $1,000 but has recently made only a few external sales and thus has plenty of spare capacity at present. Roy wants to maximise the profits of his Assembly division. Therefore, using a marginal costing approach, based on the marketing consultant s demand estimates and Assembly s costings based on the present transfer prices (above), Roy has calculated the price-volume combination that maximises Assembly division profits: Price Variable cost/unit Contribution/unit Unit sales Total contribution $ 3,000 2,600 400 550 220,000 $ $ 3,500 4,000 2,600 2,600 900 1,400 420 325 378,000 455,000 $ 4,500 2,600 1,900 250 475,000 $ 5,000 2,600 2,400 190 456,000 Tom Petty, manager of the Bodies division, tells you that Bodies could sell equivalent bodies for $530 in the external market and in fact has had to turn away external business in order to supply Assembly with the bodies they require. REQUIRED Prepare a consultant s report to the MD of Wellington Trailers Ltd, Jeff Lynne. Your report should cover the following: (a) Explain how a firm should arrive at the theoretically optimum transfer price (for maximisation of group profits) and apply this theory to the situation described at WT to calculate revised transfer prices for chassis and bodies supplied to Assembly. Give full reasons for your choice of transfer price. (b) Using the transfer prices determined in (a) above, produce a revised Assembly division costing for the Titan trailer, a revised marginal costing operating statement and state the price-volume combination that now maximises profits for Assembly division. Compare this price-volume combination to the one based on the old transfer prices. (c) Explain the key characteristics of a good transfer pricing system and use these to outline the advantages and disadvantages of the theoretically optimum transfer prices suggested in (a). (d) State and briefly explain the range of possible transfer prices within which Bob Dylan (Chassis) and Roy Orbison (Assembly) might seek agreement, if they were free to negotiate a transfer price for chassis. Establish whether they would be likely to reach agreement, and if so at about what price?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
A The total price is Market value Any price set above will not be equal to the purchase price This will result in the buyer buying from an external su... View the full answer
Related Book For
Advanced Accounting
ISBN: 978-0538480284
11th edition
Authors: Paul M. Fischer, William J. Tayler, Rita H. Cheng
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
Heavenly Chocolates manufactures and sells quality chocolate products at its plant and retail store located in Saratoga Springs, New York. Two years ago, the company developed a Web site and began...
-
Wellington Manufacturing manufactures industrial ovens used primarily in the process of coating or painting metals. The ovens are sold throughout the world, and units are manufactured to customers...
-
Quality Pool Accessory Ltd manufactures a variety of accessory equipment for swimming pools. For many years the company has used a traditional product costing system with direct labour hours as the...
-
Economic crises tend to occur sporadically virtually every decade and in various countries ranging from Sweden to Argentina, from Russia to Korea, and from Japan to the United States. Each crisis is...
-
The A atoms are red, and the B atoms are blue. Is the reaction exothermic or endothermic?
-
Delta Company produces a single product. The cost of producing and selling a single unit of this product at the company's normal activity level of 60,000 units per year is: Direct materials . . . . ....
-
Explain why it is important to report communicable diseases, adverse drug reactions, and infectious diseases.
-
If we can get that new robot to combine with our other automated equipment, well have a complete flexible manufacturing system (FMS) in place in our Northridge plant, said Hal Swain, production...
-
Determine the total dollar amount for each classification; asset, liability, stockholder's equity. Suppose the following items were taken from the balance sheet of Nike, Inc. (All dollars are in...
-
The restaurant owner Lobster Jack wants to find out what the peak demand periods are, during the hours of operation, in order to be better prepared to serve his customers. He thinks that, on average,...
-
Match the Cooperative Strategy with the description that fits it best. Question 4 options: Companies share a facility or service territory Companies try to outdo one another in reaching a shared goal...
-
Once you have identified a conflict of interest, how do you plan to maintain this standard? "Clarify the role of the health and wellness coach, establish boundaries, and discuss conflicts of interest...
-
How is social media a semi-autonomous social field? Explain
-
Which communication method is good for distributing information to large groups?
-
According to Lineberger, what are some of the social factors that contribute to health disparities?
-
Please pick a creative topic Locate & Compose For this activity, locate an example of an instructions and/or manuals you find interesting or compelling. Choose an example you find compelling or...
-
Consider the following points. (-3, 7), (6,0) and (6, 7) Step 2 of 2: What is the area of the triangle? (Hint: Make use of the midpoint formula if the triangle is isosceles.)
-
With your classmates, form small teams of skunkworks. Your task is to identify an innovation that you think would benefit your school, college, or university, and to outline an action plan for...
-
Based on the following very limited information, indicate whether and how the city should report its related entity. 1. Its school district, although not a legally separate government, is managed by...
-
Baker Company acquires an 80% interest in the common stock of Cain Company for $440,000 on January 1, 2011. The price is equal to the book value of the interest acquired. Baker Company maintains its...
-
At the beginning of the current year, Skeeba Manufacturing borrowed $10 million to be repaid over the next five calendar quarters with quarterly payments of $2,090,893.23 based on a fixed annual...
-
A blender does 5000 J of work on the food in its bowl. During the time the blender runs, 2000 J of heat is transferred from the warm food to the cooler environment. What is the change in the thermal...
-
Which system contains more atoms: 5 mol of helium (A = 4) or 1 mol of neon (A = 20)? A. Helium B. Neon C. They have the same number of atoms.
-
A sample of ideal gas is in a sealed container. The temperature of the gas and the volume of the container are both increased. What other properties of the gas necessarily change? (More than one...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App