Problem 3. Yet another previous midterm exam problem. Consider the responses shown in Figure 2 from...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Problem 3. Yet another previous midterm exam problem. Consider the responses shown in Figure 2 from four PI controllers applied to a laboratory heat exchanger. When evaluated in simulation using MATLAB w/Simulink on a nominal plant model (generated from inflection point analysis on a process reaction curve), all four control systems resulted in stable closed- loop responses, although with varying performance characteristics. DEFAULT 2 HOURS HM HM HM HM VORSTR Cont. C HTEX5 HEAT EXCHANGER Cont. A 100 Cont. B y and r Cont. D 75 50 25 u d 10/19/00 17:36:25 MIN 0 120 105 90 75 60 45 AAA PO Figure 2: Heat exchanger response for various PI controllers real-life data! The signals in Figure 2 are from a real-time display of a Honeywell TPS system, interfaced to the heat exchanger. These correspond to the outlet tube temperature and its setpoint (y and r, top curve), steam valve position (u, middle curve) and inlet tube flowrate (d, bottom curve). The closed-loop responses for controllers A and B correspond to setpoint tracking scenarios, while those for controllers C and D correspond to disturbance rejection. a) Which of the two setpoint tracking controllers would you consider to be best from the standpoint of minimizing a norm criterion on the control error ec, such as the Integral Square Error (ISE) or Integral Absolute Error (IAE)? Justify your response. b) Which of the four closed-loop responses would you say is the best from the standpoint of shape and character of response (considering both controlled and manipulated vari- ables)? Explain your reasoning for the best case, and indicate one problematic issue you see in the responses for the other three. c) Which closed-loop system would you say is the least robust (i.e., it appears most sensitive to model uncertainty)? Explain. Problem 3. Yet another previous midterm exam problem. Consider the responses shown in Figure 2 from four PI controllers applied to a laboratory heat exchanger. When evaluated in simulation using MATLAB w/Simulink on a nominal plant model (generated from inflection point analysis on a process reaction curve), all four control systems resulted in stable closed- loop responses, although with varying performance characteristics. DEFAULT 2 HOURS HM HM HM HM VORSTR Cont. C HTEX5 HEAT EXCHANGER Cont. A 100 Cont. B y and r Cont. D 75 50 25 u d 10/19/00 17:36:25 MIN 0 120 105 90 75 60 45 AAA PO Figure 2: Heat exchanger response for various PI controllers real-life data! The signals in Figure 2 are from a real-time display of a Honeywell TPS system, interfaced to the heat exchanger. These correspond to the outlet tube temperature and its setpoint (y and r, top curve), steam valve position (u, middle curve) and inlet tube flowrate (d, bottom curve). The closed-loop responses for controllers A and B correspond to setpoint tracking scenarios, while those for controllers C and D correspond to disturbance rejection. a) Which of the two setpoint tracking controllers would you consider to be best from the standpoint of minimizing a norm criterion on the control error ec, such as the Integral Square Error (ISE) or Integral Absolute Error (IAE)? Justify your response. b) Which of the four closed-loop responses would you say is the best from the standpoint of shape and character of response (considering both controlled and manipulated vari- ables)? Explain your reasoning for the best case, and indicate one problematic issue you see in the responses for the other three. c) Which closed-loop system would you say is the least robust (i.e., it appears most sensitive to model uncertainty)? Explain.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these chemical engineering questions
-
a. Example 13-1: Batch Reactor with an Exothermic Reaction Wolfram 1. Adiabatic Case: Use Wolfram to see whether you can find a trajectory that is ready to ignite and whose trajectory looks like a...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Suzanne acquired the following ordinary shares in Quarine plc: She made no further acquisitions and the shares were valued at 3.20 each on 31 March 1982. On 24 July 2020, Suzanne sold 1,200 shares...
-
a. Find for each of the following values of the population mean: 74,72,70,68, and 66. b. Plot each value of B you obtained in part a against its associated population mean. Show B on the vertical...
-
After you have studied Economics in the News on pp. 720 721 , answer the following questions. a. What was the state of the Japanese economy in 2013? b. Explain the effects of Japans high level of...
-
Distinguish between accounting and bookkeeping - be brief and think in terms of, say, what the differences in training would need to be for employment in those professions.
-
The following is the monthly payroll of Andersen Company, owned by Donald Andersen. Employees are paid on the last day of each month. Andersen Company is located at 2 Square Street, Marblehead, MA...
-
(A) We are given three diffent vectors: A = 6-3, B=-11+5j and C = A + B. (1) C = 2, (2) C = 51, (3) C = 5 + 2), (4) C=7+8 What is C in component form? A. 3 B. 1 C. 4 D. 2 Using the same three vectors...
-
Precizion is a company that makes digital cameras. Since the early 2000s, the company has lost a considerable portion of its customer base due to the entry of smart phones on the market. These days...
-
Problem 4 (6 points) Suppose g(x) is a monic polynomial of even degree d, that is g(x) = xd +bd-1xd1 + +6x+bo ...
-
In a triangle ABC, the measure of angle B is 3 times the measure of angle A, and the measure of angle C is 12 less than 6 times the measure of angle A Find the measure of the angles. The measure of...
-
Shane purchases a retirement annuity that will pay him $1,500 at the end of every six months for the first ten years and $600 at the end of every month for the next six years. The annuity earns...
-
As the manager of the human resources department at your firm, you are investigating the number of sick days employees took during the last calendar year. For employees in the marketing area, the...
-
Rewrite log(3x) + log(4y) as a single logarithm.
-
Write a paper on following topic: "necessary and proper" clause, article 1, section 8 of the constitution states that congress has the power "to make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for...
-
Revol Industries manufactures plastic bottles for the food industry. On average, Revol pays $76 per ton for its plastics. Revol's waste-disposal company has increased its waste-disposal charge to $57...
-
A fertilizer producing company purchases nitrates, phosphates, potash, and an inert chalk base and produces four different fertilizers A, B,C, and D. The cost of these nitrates, phosphates, potash,...
-
We are interested to produce $P$ in the reaction $A ightarrow P$ using a continuous reactor at $v=240$ liters/ hr with $C_{A_{0}}=3$ moles/liter. However, it is noticed that there is a second...
-
Heavy fuel oil, initially semisolid at $15^{\circ} \mathrm{C}$ is to be heated and pumped through a $15 \mathrm{~cm}$ diameter (inside) pipe at the rate of $20000 \mathrm{~kg} / \mathrm{h}$. The pipe...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App