What are the pros and cons of waiting for a year before deciding whether to invest? Ecsy-Cola18
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
What are the pros and cons of waiting for a year before deciding whether to invest?
Transcribed Image Text:
Ecsy-Cola18 Libby Flannery, the regional manager of Ecsy-Cola, the international soft drinks empire, was reviewing her investment plans for Central Asia. She had contemplated launching Ecsy- Cola in the ex-Soviet republic of Inglistan in 2004. This would involve a capital outlay of $20 million in 2004 to build a bottling plant and set up a distribution system there. Fixed costs (for manufacturing, distribution, and marketing) would then be $3 million per year from 2003 onward. This would be sufficient to make and sell 200 million liters per year-enough for every man, woman, and child in Inglistan to drink four bottles per week! But there would be few savings from building a smaller plant, and import tariffs and transport costs in the region would keep all production within national borders. The variable costs of production and distribution would be 12 cents per liter. Company policy requires a rate of return of 25 percent in nominal dollar terms, after local taxes but be- fore deducting any costs of financing. The sales revenue is forecasted to be 35 cents per liter. Bottling plants last almost forever, and all unit costs and revenues were expected to re- main constant in nominal terms. Tax would be payable at a rate of 30 percent, and under the Inglistan corporate tax code, capital expenditures can be written off on a straight-line basis over four years. All these inputs were reasonably clear. But Ms. Flannery racked her brain trying to fore- cast sales. Ecsy-Cola found that the "1-2-4" rule works in most new markets. Sales typically double in the second year, double again in the third year, and after that remain roughly con- stant. Libby's best guess was that, if she went ahead immediately, initial sales in Inglistan would be 12.5 million liters in 2005, ramping up to 50 million in 2007 and onward. Ms. Flannery also worried whether it would be better to wait a year. The soft drink market was developing rapidly in neighboring countries, and in a year's time she should have a much better idea whether Ecsy-Cola would be likely to catch on in Inglistan. If it didn't catch on and sales stalled below 20 million liters, a large investment probably would not be justified. Ms. Flannery had assumed that Ecsy-Cola's keen rival, Sparky-Cola, would not also enter the market. But last week she received a shock when in the lobby of the Kapitaliste Hotel she bumped into her opposite number at Sparky-Cola. Sparky-Cola would face costs similar to Ecsy-Cola. How would Sparky-Cola respond if Ecsy-Cola entered the market? Would it de- cide to enter also? If so, how would that affect the profitability of Ecsy-Cola's project? Ms. Flannery thought again about postponing investment for a year. Suppose Sparky-Cola was interested in the Inglistan market. Would that favor delay or immediate action? Maybe Ecsy-Cola should announce its plans before Sparky-Cola had a chance to develop its own pro- posals. It seemed that the Inglistan project was becoming more complicated by the day. Ecsy-Cola18 Libby Flannery, the regional manager of Ecsy-Cola, the international soft drinks empire, was reviewing her investment plans for Central Asia. She had contemplated launching Ecsy- Cola in the ex-Soviet republic of Inglistan in 2004. This would involve a capital outlay of $20 million in 2004 to build a bottling plant and set up a distribution system there. Fixed costs (for manufacturing, distribution, and marketing) would then be $3 million per year from 2003 onward. This would be sufficient to make and sell 200 million liters per year-enough for every man, woman, and child in Inglistan to drink four bottles per week! But there would be few savings from building a smaller plant, and import tariffs and transport costs in the region would keep all production within national borders. The variable costs of production and distribution would be 12 cents per liter. Company policy requires a rate of return of 25 percent in nominal dollar terms, after local taxes but be- fore deducting any costs of financing. The sales revenue is forecasted to be 35 cents per liter. Bottling plants last almost forever, and all unit costs and revenues were expected to re- main constant in nominal terms. Tax would be payable at a rate of 30 percent, and under the Inglistan corporate tax code, capital expenditures can be written off on a straight-line basis over four years. All these inputs were reasonably clear. But Ms. Flannery racked her brain trying to fore- cast sales. Ecsy-Cola found that the "1-2-4" rule works in most new markets. Sales typically double in the second year, double again in the third year, and after that remain roughly con- stant. Libby's best guess was that, if she went ahead immediately, initial sales in Inglistan would be 12.5 million liters in 2005, ramping up to 50 million in 2007 and onward. Ms. Flannery also worried whether it would be better to wait a year. The soft drink market was developing rapidly in neighboring countries, and in a year's time she should have a much better idea whether Ecsy-Cola would be likely to catch on in Inglistan. If it didn't catch on and sales stalled below 20 million liters, a large investment probably would not be justified. Ms. Flannery had assumed that Ecsy-Cola's keen rival, Sparky-Cola, would not also enter the market. But last week she received a shock when in the lobby of the Kapitaliste Hotel she bumped into her opposite number at Sparky-Cola. Sparky-Cola would face costs similar to Ecsy-Cola. How would Sparky-Cola respond if Ecsy-Cola entered the market? Would it de- cide to enter also? If so, how would that affect the profitability of Ecsy-Cola's project? Ms. Flannery thought again about postponing investment for a year. Suppose Sparky-Cola was interested in the Inglistan market. Would that favor delay or immediate action? Maybe Ecsy-Cola should announce its plans before Sparky-Cola had a chance to develop its own pro- posals. It seemed that the Inglistan project was becoming more complicated by the day.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Pros Company gets a better idea of the market demand by waiting and observing the market closely Com... View the full answer
Related Book For
Visualizing Environmental Science
ISBN: 978-1119147527
4th edition
Authors: Linda R. Berg, David M. Hassenzahl, Mary Catherine Hager
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
What are the pros and cons of using geothermal energy to produce electricity? What are the pros and cons of using tidal power to produce electricity?
-
What are the pros and cons of change? Does it help or hurt organizational performance? Do you like change? Why or why not?
-
What are the pros and cons of linking incentive pay to individual performance? How can organizations address the negatives?
-
Top executive officers of Preston Company, a merchandising firm, are preparing the next years budget. The controller has provided everyone with the current years projected income statement. Current...
-
The following table provides a frequency distribution for the ages of adult women seeking pregnancy tests at public health facilities in Missouri during a 3-month period. It appeared in the article...
-
Smoky Mountain Corporation makes two types of hiking bootsXtreme and the Pathfinder. Data concerning these two product lines appear below: The company has a traditional costing system in which...
-
Which method of estimating uncollectible receivables focuses on net credit sales? a. Aging approach b. Percent-of-sales approach C. Net realizable value approach d. All of the above
-
On December 12, 2013, Pace Electronics received $24,000 from a customer toward a cash sale of $240,000 of diodes to be completed on January 16, 2014. What journal entries should Pace record on...
-
4. Record the journal entry that results from the source document shown below on the fourth worksheet tab (labelled "Question IV"). 3783 Desig. No. Account 0265 082475-32 YOUR ACCOUNT HAS BEEN...
-
Based on the information provided in the case, illustrate the pricing game between Sony and Microsoft using a 2-by-2 payoff matrix when Sony and Microsoft charge for their games $399, or lower price...
-
How did civilization program threaten the culture and way of life of Native Americans ?do you believe the program was successful? why or why not ? Explain
-
Tesla, the world's largest carmaker (as determined by market capitalization), understands that their primary target market responds well to brands that focus on social responsibility. Tesla's senior...
-
What surprised you most about services provider in your daily life? Has being more aware about the foundations of service marketing changed the way you view your interaction with service providers?...
-
Consider the following figure. P (MPa) 8 6 4 2 i 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 V (m) (a) Determine the work done on a fluid that expands from i to f as indicated in the figure. MJ (b) How much work is done on the...
-
Identify a recent verbal communication you were involved in, perhaps one that you felt uncomfortable about, and write it down in the space provided (we have given an example). Communication I was...
-
Read Case #12, "Grand Targhee," in the Case Studies section near the end of your textbook. Also visit the website www.grandtarghee.com Analyze the product by answering the questions below. You will...
-
Suppose an investment bank is buying $50 million in long-term mortgage-backed securities, and finances the investment by borrowing 80% and paying for the other 20% out of equity. What is the bank's...
-
A company has the following incomplete production budget data for the first quarter: In the previous December, ending inventory was 200 units, which was the minimum required, at 10% of projected...
-
Which international treaties aim to protect ocean resources?
-
How do conservation easements help protect privately owned rangelands?
-
How does per person energy consumption compare in highly developed and developing countries?
-
Consider the quarterly real GDP of United Kingdom, Canada, and the United States from the first quarter of 1980 to the second quarter of 2011. The data are available from the Federal Reserve Bank of...
-
Derive the error-correction form in Equation (5.68) for a \(\operatorname{VAR}(p)\) model. P-1 Azt = zt-p+Azti + c(t) + (B)at, i=1 (5.68)
-
Housing markets in the United States have been under pressure since the 2007 subprime financial crisis. In this problem, we consider the housing starts for the West and South regions of U.S. Census....
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App