What is a 'stateless' society? 2. How is political status achieved in Papua New Guinea compared...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
What is a 'stateless' society? 2. How is political status achieved in Papua New Guinea compared to some societies in Africa and the Eastern Pacific? 3. The article notes five qualities that an ambitious man must have if he wants to achieve success and rise above the crowd in Papua New Guinea society. One is talent. What are the other four? Fill in the blanks: He must be a gd! people. He must have g grand powerful speaker. He must be p thy and ch ma. ive and good at managing 4. How does the author compare the moką ceremony with the United States Presidential debates? Article: The 'Big Men' of Papua New Guinea & Their Western Counterpart Retrieved from https://www.zegrahm.com/blog/big-men-papua-new-quinea-their-western-counterpart September 2018 Shirley Campbell is a social anthropologist with a special interest in the indigenous peoples of Australia, Melanesia, and the Pacific. After growing up in California, she has widely traveled and experienced firsthand the ways in which communities form and develop distinct, yet interrelated cultures. As I followed the 2016 electoral process in the United States, I couldn't help but reflect upon the similarities between the popular selection of a leader in the self-proclaimed greatest democracy in the world, with that found in much of Melanesia, including the island of Papua New Guinea, a process that positions certain men, 'Big Men,' into leadership roles based on their persuasive, oratorical qualities and the strategies utilized to demonstrate their successes. While this comparison can only go so far, the elements of chest pounding and bravado operating in both hemispheres, provide the kind of theater that both horrifies and captivates us, the voters. From the middle of the last century, anthropologists working on the island of Papua New Guinea described a unique kind of political behavior. Although the majority of societies are classified as 'stateless-that is, without formal political institutions circumscribing social and political boundaries and no formal positions of power for ... men to occupy-there were men who clearly held culturally recognized positions of leadership. These were wwww labeled 'Big Man' systems. In these societies, leadership is determined through informal processes. A man's support base relied on his powers of persuasion. This was drastically different from what had been recorded from political systems in Africa and the eastern Pacific, where formal systems of inherited political status affirmed one's succession into power. In those areas, one simply needed to be born into the right lineage and, in many cases, be the first born to secure political power and privilege. Birthright does not play as much as role in gaining political power in Papua New Guinea societies. 'Big Man' politics found in Papua New Guinea is essentially an egalitarian form of social and political behavior in that 'all men are equal,' and no man has power over any other. However, as in most communities, there are those who are more ambitious and see their life goals directed towards becoming even 'bigger than their 'equal' others. While there were no positions of power within a structured political framework to be filled, and no formal avenues towards exercising power over others in much of pre-colonial Papua New Guinea, there were always ways for promotion ahead of one's brothers, uncles, sons, fathers-in-law, and fathers. A man with ambitions to rise above the crowd must have talent. He has to appear to be a good listener and have an ability to persuade people to give up their wealth to support his goals. A 'Big Man' is someone who can empathize with the plight of his brethren while simultaneously persuading them that their cause is his cause. This talent requires the gift of charisma. He has to be able to persuade people both in the quiet of their homes and gardens, as well as in the public arena, that his goals are the same as theirs and that together, they can achieve greatness. Sound familiar? Without a hierarchical system of inheritance, each man is the architect of his own success. The 'Big Man' has to rise from the ranks by plotting his advancement via social avenues available to every other man. He has to do it better. For example, in Papua New Guinea a man can take on more wives, thereby garnering more pigs and thus, status, through 'bride price,' as well as support from new in-laws. In the same way, United States presidential candidates have to make their own way to the top through informally recognized pathways. With an eye fixed upon the top 'job, Big Men' and United States presidents have to build their 'names, using all given opportunities available along a social trajectory to make their names 'big.' While in both systems there is the notion, at least in theory, that the pinnacle of social and political power is open to everyone, it does help to have had a relative or two who has paved the road in one way or another. Although being the son of a 'Big Man' helps a young man with ambitions, it is by no means a guarantee of success. Clearly with the accumulated wealth of a 'Big Man' to draw upon, a young man has a leg up, as it were. A 'Big Man' has to be adept at managing people. He has to take individuals with him, leading them towards a desired outcome, in order to build a strong and growing base of followers who are willing to provide support in wealth and in labor-to achieve their perceived joint ends. Finally, he has to be able to amass more wealth than others so that he can give it away in lavish ceremonies, where men vie with each other to be the most beautifully decorated, the loudest and most persuasive, and to have the most to give away. Again, that strikes a chord with the televised debates we saw during the 2016 United States electoral debates. While the US presidential candidates are not standing at the podium covered in paint, pig fat, and feathers, their apparel has been carefully selected to convey a desired message, their hair Unite best offer coiffed to the best effect, and their demeanor designed to contrast with that of their rivals. Vying to be the loudest has increasingly become a feature of these debates. To watch a New Guinea 'Big Man' railing against his competitors, attempting to rouse the loyalty of his supporters, would be nothing less exotic than to watch the 2016 US presidential electoral process. What is a 'stateless' society? 2. How is political status achieved in Papua New Guinea compared to some societies in Africa and the Eastern Pacific? 3. The article notes five qualities that an ambitious man must have if he wants to achieve success and rise above the crowd in Papua New Guinea society. One is talent. What are the other four? Fill in the blanks: He must be a gd! people. He must have g grand powerful speaker. He must be p thy and ch ma. ive and good at managing 4. How does the author compare the moką ceremony with the United States Presidential debates? Article: The 'Big Men' of Papua New Guinea & Their Western Counterpart Retrieved from https://www.zegrahm.com/blog/big-men-papua-new-quinea-their-western-counterpart September 2018 Shirley Campbell is a social anthropologist with a special interest in the indigenous peoples of Australia, Melanesia, and the Pacific. After growing up in California, she has widely traveled and experienced firsthand the ways in which communities form and develop distinct, yet interrelated cultures. As I followed the 2016 electoral process in the United States, I couldn't help but reflect upon the similarities between the popular selection of a leader in the self-proclaimed greatest democracy in the world, with that found in much of Melanesia, including the island of Papua New Guinea, a process that positions certain men, 'Big Men,' into leadership roles based on their persuasive, oratorical qualities and the strategies utilized to demonstrate their successes. While this comparison can only go so far, the elements of chest pounding and bravado operating in both hemispheres, provide the kind of theater that both horrifies and captivates us, the voters. From the middle of the last century, anthropologists working on the island of Papua New Guinea described a unique kind of political behavior. Although the majority of societies are classified as 'stateless-that is, without formal political institutions circumscribing social and political boundaries and no formal positions of power for ... men to occupy-there were men who clearly held culturally recognized positions of leadership. These were wwww labeled 'Big Man' systems. In these societies, leadership is determined through informal processes. A man's support base relied on his powers of persuasion. This was drastically different from what had been recorded from political systems in Africa and the eastern Pacific, where formal systems of inherited political status affirmed one's succession into power. In those areas, one simply needed to be born into the right lineage and, in many cases, be the first born to secure political power and privilege. Birthright does not play as much as role in gaining political power in Papua New Guinea societies. 'Big Man' politics found in Papua New Guinea is essentially an egalitarian form of social and political behavior in that 'all men are equal,' and no man has power over any other. However, as in most communities, there are those who are more ambitious and see their life goals directed towards becoming even 'bigger than their 'equal' others. While there were no positions of power within a structured political framework to be filled, and no formal avenues towards exercising power over others in much of pre-colonial Papua New Guinea, there were always ways for promotion ahead of one's brothers, uncles, sons, fathers-in-law, and fathers. A man with ambitions to rise above the crowd must have talent. He has to appear to be a good listener and have an ability to persuade people to give up their wealth to support his goals. A 'Big Man' is someone who can empathize with the plight of his brethren while simultaneously persuading them that their cause is his cause. This talent requires the gift of charisma. He has to be able to persuade people both in the quiet of their homes and gardens, as well as in the public arena, that his goals are the same as theirs and that together, they can achieve greatness. Sound familiar? Without a hierarchical system of inheritance, each man is the architect of his own success. The 'Big Man' has to rise from the ranks by plotting his advancement via social avenues available to every other man. He has to do it better. For example, in Papua New Guinea a man can take on more wives, thereby garnering more pigs and thus, status, through 'bride price,' as well as support from new in-laws. In the same way, United States presidential candidates have to make their own way to the top through informally recognized pathways. With an eye fixed upon the top 'job, Big Men' and United States presidents have to build their 'names, using all given opportunities available along a social trajectory to make their names 'big.' While in both systems there is the notion, at least in theory, that the pinnacle of social and political power is open to everyone, it does help to have had a relative or two who has paved the road in one way or another. Although being the son of a 'Big Man' helps a young man with ambitions, it is by no means a guarantee of success. Clearly with the accumulated wealth of a 'Big Man' to draw upon, a young man has a leg up, as it were. A 'Big Man' has to be adept at managing people. He has to take individuals with him, leading them towards a desired outcome, in order to build a strong and growing base of followers who are willing to provide support in wealth and in labor-to achieve their perceived joint ends. Finally, he has to be able to amass more wealth than others so that he can give it away in lavish ceremonies, where men vie with each other to be the most beautifully decorated, the loudest and most persuasive, and to have the most to give away. Again, that strikes a chord with the televised debates we saw during the 2016 United States electoral debates. While the US presidential candidates are not standing at the podium covered in paint, pig fat, and feathers, their apparel has been carefully selected to convey a desired message, their hair Unite best offer coiffed to the best effect, and their demeanor designed to contrast with that of their rivals. Vying to be the loudest has increasingly become a feature of these debates. To watch a New Guinea 'Big Man' railing against his competitors, attempting to rouse the loyalty of his supporters, would be nothing less exotic than to watch the 2016 US presidential electoral process.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Stateless Society A stateless society refers to a social and political organization that lacks formal political institutions government structures a... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these databases questions
-
On December 15, a small company starts transitioning to a new accounting package during their holiday break. Suddenly, on January 2, when employees return to work at 9:00 a.m., all computers in the...
-
What amount of michaels capital stock transactions are added to gross income on his 1040?
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Graph the solution sets in Problems 316. x 100
-
Rail guns have been suggested for launching projectiles into space without chemical rockets, and for ground-to-air antimissile weapons of war. A tabletop model rail gun (Fig. P30.61) consists of two...
-
If the cycle time for the paint cell is 60 seconds, how long will the painted parts in Figure 43-14 have to dry?
-
During the year ended 30 June 2025, Smart Chips Pty Ltd incurred the following costs in connection with its production activities. Required (a) Calculate the relationship between factory overhead...
-
Martin Company has a line of credit with Federal Bank. Martin can borrow up to $600,000 at any time over the course of the 2013 calendar year. The following table shows the prime rate expressed as an...
-
A disk of radius 3.00 m rotates like a merry-go-round as given by the function 0 = 2.00t4 + 6.00t, where is in radians and t is in seconds. What is the tangential acceleration (m/s) of a point on the...
-
Affordable Electronics Inc. manufactures medium-quality, reasonably priced wireless speakers for home use. The company uses standards to control its costs. The labour standards that have been set for...
-
How much is the total Liabilities of the business? The following information were generated from the records of MM Medical Clinic as of December 31, 2020: Cash Patents Equipment Accrued expenses...
-
Write a two to three pages summary plan that exploits the technology highlighted in the TED talk video below for innovative business opportunities and solutions. The plan should describe the...
-
Using the phase-gate process, How does understanding consumer wants and needs impact the process of generating and developing successful product ideas, and how can companies help ensure that the...
-
Tsaltz orthotics Inc is a operating a new plant in Hamilton, Ontario. Easton, distribution manager, has been asked to find the lowest cost outbound logistics system. Given an annual sales of 61,000...
-
Examples of an conclusion paragraph containing how managers can shape behavior using positive and negative reinforcement, locus of control , Maslow's need hierarchy, the three-needs theory, and the...
-
Below is an article that describes three examples of successful B2B marketing campaigns. Identify and explain which market it operates in (industrial, reseller, or government) Explain the market and...
-
A circuit and the signal applied at its input terminals (V) are shown in figure below. Which one of the options correctly describes the output waveform (V). (Assume all the devices used are ideal)....
-
Assume you are the accountant for Catalina Industries. John Catalina, the owner of the company, is in a hurry to receive the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 20X1, and asks you...
-
(a) If f (x) e x cos x, find f'(x) and f''(x). (b) Check to see that your answers to part (a) are reasonable by graphing f , f', and f''.
-
When we estimate distances from velocity data, it is sometimes necessary to use times t 0 , t 1 , t 2 , t 3 , . . . that are not equally spaced. We can still estimate distances using the time periods...
-
A region R in the xy-plane is given. Find equations for a transformation T that maps a rectangular region S in the uv-plane onto R, where the sides of S are parallel to the u- and v-axes. R is the...
-
(a) Determine the equivalent torsional stiffness of the propeller shaft of Problem 2.24. (b) Determine an equivalent moment of inertia of the shaft of Problem 2.24 to be placed on the end of the...
-
A block of mass \(m\) is connected to two identical springs in series. Each spring has a mass \(\mathrm{m}\) and a stiffness \(\mathrm{k}\). Determine the equivalent mass of the two springs at the...
-
Show that the inertia effects of a torsional shaft of polar mass moment of inertia \(J\) can be approximated by adding a thin disk of moment of inertia \(J / 3\) at the end of the shaft.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App