Analyze the structure of the analogical arguments in the following passages, and evaluate them in terms of the six criteria that have been explained:

It would be the height of hypocrisy if Pete Rose, one of baseball’s star players, were allowed back into baseball and elected to the Hall of Fame after finally admitting that he placed bets on his team and other teams and lied about it. In coming to a decision about Rose, the Baseball Commissioner should remember that Olympic athletes who have been caught using performance-enhancing drugs are stripped permanently of their titles and medals.
—Frank Ulrich, The New York Times , 8 January 2004