Case Analysis Format for "A Case Study of Budgetary Ethics"$1.$ Leadership in the budget process:$($a$)$ What kind of leadership did the Mayor display?$($b$)$ Is the kind of leadership displayed effective for advancing democracy and community building?$($c$)$ Which ethical value was violated at the:$($i$)$ Political level:$($ii$)$ Procedural Level:$($iii$)$ Personal Level:$2.$ Important of budget procedures:$($a$)$ How did the adoption of new procedure affect the budgetary process?$($b$)$ How did the change in budget decision process affect policy?$($c$)$ What kind of policy is needed in terms of the budget procedure dealing with performance?$3.$ Relationship between budget procedure and public service values:$($a$)$ Which public service values underlie the change in budget decision?$($b$)$ Which public service values are not supported by the change in budget decision?$($c$)$ Which value ranks higher in importance given the financial and political context of thejurisdiction?$4.$ Ethical dilemma faced by the budget actors and the choices made:What ethical dilemma did each of the following actors face and what ethical choices did they make?$($a$)$ Mayor$($b$)$ Police Chief$($c$)$ OPI Director$($d$)$ OPI Analyst$($e$)$ Which ethical choices do you think promotes democratic administration in so far the budget process is concerned?$5.$ Relationship between political and professional criteria:$($a$)$ How do you see political and professional criteria in conflict?$($b$)$ How would you bring the political and professional criteria in alignment for effective democratic governance?