CRA has observed that randomly selecting returns for investigation is expensive and not productive. As noted...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
CRA has observed that randomly selecting returns for investigation is expensive and not productive. As noted in question 1, 88% of these returns are complete. Only 12% warranted investigation. However, they have observed that those that are incomplete (and potentially fraudulent) often exhibit characteristics that differentiate themselves from complete returns. Suppose CRA has built a model to predict which returns are incomplete and has applied it to the 100,000 cases used in question 1. The results of the model are as follows: Prediction Truth Incomplete Complete Total Incomplete 8,900 3,100 12,000 Complete 11,100 76,900 88,000 Total 20,000 80,000 100,000 a. What is the accuracy rate for this model? Explain the meaning of "accuracy rate" in words that an average person would understand. b. What is the "sensitivity rate" for the model? Explain the meaning of this "sensitivity rate" in words an average person would understand. With respect to defining "positive" and "negative" for measuring true/false positive/negative, CRA is trying to identify incomplete tax returns, so "incomplete" is "positive" and "complete" is "negative". c. What is the "specificity rate" for the model? Explain the meaning of this "specificity rate" in words an average person would understand. d. What is the "false omission rate for the model? Explain the meaning of this "false omission rate" in words an average person would understand. e. What is the "false detection rate" for the model? Explain the meaning of this "false detection rate" in words an average person would understand. f. Suppose that on average, investigating a tax return costs CRA $1,000 in staff costs (some are inexpensive but some cost many $1,000s of $$). Suppose that, on average, finding an incomplete return leads to the collection of an additional $6,000 in taxes. If CRA used the above model and investigated only those cases that it predicted were incomplete, what would be the expected average benefit per return? This can be done by converting the frequencies in the above confusion matrix to probabilities and calculating expected value. Alternatively, you can calculate the total cost and extra taxes collected for the above 100,000 individuals and then convert the total to an average per person. g. If CRA chose to not use the model and investigate all 100,000 returns (like they did in question 1), what would be the expected average benefit per return? CRA has observed that randomly selecting returns for investigation is expensive and not productive. As noted in question 1, 88% of these returns are complete. Only 12% warranted investigation. However, they have observed that those that are incomplete (and potentially fraudulent) often exhibit characteristics that differentiate themselves from complete returns. Suppose CRA has built a model to predict which returns are incomplete and has applied it to the 100,000 cases used in question 1. The results of the model are as follows: Prediction Truth Incomplete Complete Total Incomplete 8,900 3,100 12,000 Complete 11,100 76,900 88,000 Total 20,000 80,000 100,000 a. What is the accuracy rate for this model? Explain the meaning of "accuracy rate" in words that an average person would understand. b. What is the "sensitivity rate" for the model? Explain the meaning of this "sensitivity rate" in words an average person would understand. With respect to defining "positive" and "negative" for measuring true/false positive/negative, CRA is trying to identify incomplete tax returns, so "incomplete" is "positive" and "complete" is "negative". c. What is the "specificity rate" for the model? Explain the meaning of this "specificity rate" in words an average person would understand. d. What is the "false omission rate for the model? Explain the meaning of this "false omission rate" in words an average person would understand. e. What is the "false detection rate" for the model? Explain the meaning of this "false detection rate" in words an average person would understand. f. Suppose that on average, investigating a tax return costs CRA $1,000 in staff costs (some are inexpensive but some cost many $1,000s of $$). Suppose that, on average, finding an incomplete return leads to the collection of an additional $6,000 in taxes. If CRA used the above model and investigated only those cases that it predicted were incomplete, what would be the expected average benefit per return? This can be done by converting the frequencies in the above confusion matrix to probabilities and calculating expected value. Alternatively, you can calculate the total cost and extra taxes collected for the above 100,000 individuals and then convert the total to an average per person. g. If CRA chose to not use the model and investigate all 100,000 returns (like they did in question 1), what would be the expected average benefit per return?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
a Accuracy rate calculation Correct classifications Total classifications Incomplete Complete Total ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Auditing Cases An Interactive Learning Approach
ISBN: 9780134421827
7th Edition
Authors: Mark S Beasley, Frank A. Buckless, Steven M. Glover, Douglas F Prawitt
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Case Study: Quick Fix Dental Practice Technology requirements Application must be built using Visual Studio 2019 or Visual Studio 2017, professional or enterprise. The community edition is not...
-
For numbers a and b, determine which of the following expressions equals the given expression. (a) a + b (b) a b (c) b a (d) a b a + (b)
-
The lower side of a 400-mm-diameter disk is heated by an electric furnace, while the upper side is exposed to quiescent, ambient air and surroundings at 300 K. The radiant furnace (negligible...
-
The following list of accounts was provided by Churyk Transportation Corporation, which has an April 30 fiscal year-end. Using these accounts, prepare a balance sheet for Churyk Transportation...
-
The A-36 steel bar consists of two segments, one of circular cross section of radius \(r\), and one of square cross section. If the bar is subjected to the axial loading of \(P\), determine the...
-
The following information concerns production in the Baking Department for July. All direct materials are placed in process at the beginning of production. a. Determine the number of units in work in...
-
Given the follwing 2 Test Cancer Bayesian Network and the probabilities below, T1 C T P(C)=0,01 P(+ | C)=0,9 P(NOT C)=0,99 P(-| C)=0,1 P(-| NOT C)=0,9 P(+ | NOT C)=0,1| Calculate P(C | T1=+, T2=-) = ?
-
Alan and Angel Young are both 36 years old. Mr. Young recently accepted a new job making $93,000 a year and Mrs. Young is currently unemployed. The Youngs have two children (ages 4 and 2), a dog, and...
-
Your Netflix subscription is about to expire, and the company offers you three renewal options: Question 15Answer a. Pay $100 now for a four-year subscription. b. Pay $32 per year at the end of each...
-
What identifies required actions over a five- to seven-year period to attain the strategic goal(s) specified by the organization?
-
Our department needs a new copier, and your job is to research the options. Based on your research, you have selected an all-in-one machine that you believe will be cost effective and will perform...
-
Calculate raw material cost per pound sold, for each source. 4. Calculate direct labor cost per pound sold for: a. Grading. b. Cutting. (consider yields carefully). 5. Calculate packing cost (labor...
-
Affordable Beauty Supply produces inexpensive combs, brushes, and hair clips. As a way to minimize costs when sending out these small items, the company combines 10 to 12 different orders into one....
-
Jamie has inherited 500 shares of an investment company. She calls her broker to redeem the shares and is informed that the kind of investment company she owns makes no provision for future purchases...
-
MamaGold Sdn Bhd is a company which produces MG1 and MG2. The company normally manufactures 4,000 units of MG1 and 10,000 units of MG2. The direct material and direct labour costs per unit are as...
-
Using thermodynamic data from Appendix 4, calculate G at 258C for the process: 2SO 2 (g) + O 2 (g) 88n 2SO 3 (g) where all gases are at 1.00 atm pressure. Also calculate DG8 at 258C for this same...
-
Brent Dorsey graduated six months ago with a masters degree in accounting. Immediately after graduation, Brent began working with a large accounting firm in Portland, Oregon. He is now on his second...
-
John C. Koss started his first company, J.C. Koss Hospital Television Rental Company, in 1953, based in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, but John had greater ambitions. Eventually he partnered with Martin...
-
In December 1995, the flamboyant entrepreneur, Michael Mickey Monus, formerly president and chief operating officer (COO) of the deep-discount retail chain Phar-Mor, Inc., was sentenced to 19 years...
-
A construction contract differs from contracts that we generally deal with that focus on an easily defined physical object because the physical object can be examined. How is the object of a...
-
What does the owner contribute to the project and what does the contractor contribute to the project?
-
For what type of project is a line-of-balance schedule particularly suited? Identify specific examples.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App